Moved, Not Buying
John Lewis's twentieth Christmas ad is predicted to be felt and remembered, and a little less likely than usual to be acted on, which is a useful reminder that warmth and sales are two different jobs.

John Lewis’s twentieth Christmas ad is predicted to be felt and remembered, and a little less likely than usual to be acted on, which is a useful reminder that warmth and sales are two different jobs.
Picture a family somewhere in Britain this week, sitting down after dinner while someone finds the new John Lewis advert on a phone, so that three generations can watch Dame Kristin Scott Thomas, as a grandmother called Gloria, being led on a festive adventure by a vintage toy dog voiced by Paul Whitehouse. By the time Sam Fender’s cover of “You Can’t Always Get What You Want” reaches the reveal of a “Gran Cave” full of disco balls, lights and music, the room may well make the noise that British living rooms have made for this ad most Novembers, and then everybody goes back to arguing about the washing-up without anyone opening the John Lewis app.
That is not a criticism of the ad, which is carefully made and, if the predictions below are right, hard to mistake for anyone else’s. It is a description of a gap that every marketer knows and few campaign reviews admit, between being moved by something and doing something about it, and if you sign off festive creative, it is the gap your work will quietly be judged on, which makes it worth noticing that this year it comes with numbers attached, or more accurately with predictions.
What the machine expects
In a blog post on 3 November, the creative-testing company DAIVID reported what happened when it ran “Gloria and Pickles” through its platform, which it describes as trained on tens of millions of human responses to ads. The figures deserve a careful reading because they are AI-predicted responses, a forecast of how audiences are likely to react, and not a survey of people who actually watched the ad. On that basis the ad is forecast to deliver intense positive emotions 10% above the norm, to be 222% more likely than the average ad to make viewers feel nostalgic, and to have 72% of viewers correctly identify John Lewis as the brand behind it, which is 32% above the norm. Its Creative Effectiveness Score, a composite of attention, emotion and brand recall, came out at 6.61 out of 10, which DAIVID places in the 76th percentile of the ads it has tested, with predicted brand search 5% above the norm.
Then comes the part DAIVID itself calls the lump of coal in the stocking, because predicted intent to buy sat 3.1% below the norm, intent to recommend 4% below and intent to share 2.1% below. The ad was also forecast to be 15% more likely to bore viewers, which DAIVID says isn’t unusual for an ad of three minutes. In DAIVID’s own words, “the warm feelings don’t fully convert into intent.”
Two other readings add context, and they measure different things. System1, which tests ads on real viewers, gave the ad 5.6 Stars, John Lewis’s best score since 2019, although 5.6 was not quite enough for System1’s early top twelve, which Morrisons and Sainsbury’s lead. YouGov’s BrandIndex, which is based on what people say in surveys rather than on what they buy, shows John Lewis’s Ad Awareness rising by 22.1 points in the week from 2 November, a jump similar to last year’s, which speaks to recall rather than intent, while its Buzz score, which tracks whether people have heard anything positive or negative about the brand, fell by 2.8 points after rising in each of the previous two years. YouGov also notes press criticism of “confused” messaging, and Advanced Television reported that much of the press and social media reacted badly, with some calling the ad “out of touch”. System1 and DAIVID both say the ad lands emotionally, and neither measures whether anyone buys, so the fairest summary is an ad that is seen, recognised and predicted to be warmly received, in an early public mood that is mixed, without obviously giving anyone a reason to act.
Why the feeling stops short
One way to read the gap between feeling and action is through Appraisal Theory, in which emotions follow from how a person evaluates what is happening. An ad about a grandmother discovering that a present is, in DAIVID’s summary, “less about what she buys and more about the memories she creates” invites an appraisal of family, time and meaning rather than of whether this is the week to buy something. Dual Process Theory offers another possible reading, in which the fast, intuitive system that responds to nostalgia and a familiar song is not the slower, deliberate system that weighs a purchase, although many purchases are fast and intuitive too, so this is a hypothesis rather than a finding. The copywriters may have noticed that a retailer’s ad gently arguing that the best gift is not the one you buy is a lovely sentiment and a slightly awkward one.
Two jobs, one budget
If either reading is right, the usual verdict on numbers like these, that the ad has somehow failed, is too quick. Les Binet and Peter Field’s work for the IPA has long argued that emotional brand-building and short-term sales activation do different jobs over different timescales, and a department store’s Christmas film is mainly a brand-building exercise. Memory and goodwill are worth something, and a brand that 72% of viewers are predicted to name correctly may have earned itself a place in next year’s consideration, provided the prediction holds.
The lenses that were not invited
The STAR Framework looks at decisions through four situational lenses, Socialiser, Thinker, Adventurer and Realist, and what follows is my interpretation rather than anything DAIVID, YouGov or System1 tested.
Through the Socialiser lens, which centres warmth, connection and shared moments, “Gloria and Pickles” is close to perfect. In Dear Algorithm I described that lens as judging things not by “is this good?” but by “who else is doing this? Can I share it? Will it bring me closer to someone?”, and a grandmother building a cave of memories for her grandchildren answers every one of those questions. The Realist lens looks for security, stability and reliability, along with simplicity and ease, and it wants to know what the easy next step is, which the ad does not really offer beyond its tagline, “Don’t give up on giving”. The Thinker lens looks for a reason and for evidence it can weigh, compare or justify, and in three minutes there is little of that on offer. The Adventurer lens, drawn to novelty and freedom, gets a talking dog and a disco ball, which is more than it is usually offered in December.
On my untested reading, an ad that speaks fluently to one lens can leave the others unmoved, and that is a segmentation question rather than a creative failure. The same viewer can look through different lenses at different moments, so the useful question is not which people the ad reached but which moment of the decision it was built for, and whether anything else in the campaign was built for the moments that follow.
A toolkit for the feeling-to-doing gap
- Name the job before the brief. Decide whether a piece of creative is there to be remembered or to be acted on, write that down, and judge the work against the job it was given rather than against both.
- Read predictions as predictions. AI-predicted responses are a quick and useful early signal, but treat them as a hypothesis to test against sales, search and measured surveys rather than as a verdict.
- Give the Realist lens a next step. On my reading, if the campaign is meant to drive any action, the action should be obvious and easy, whether it is a gift guide, a delivery promise or a single hero product, and it should sit where the warm feeling lands.
- Give the Thinker lens a reason. Again on my reading, pair the emotional film with something that can be weighed, such as a specific product, a price promise or evidence that the gift will be used and loved, in the channels where people actually compare.
- Measure each job separately. Track memory and goodwill for the brand film and intent and conversion for the supporting work, so that one job is not blamed for failing at the other.
The test question for any Christmas campaign is simple enough to ask out loud in the room: when the warm feeling fades, what do we want people to do, and have we made it easy?
The family in that picture will go shopping at some point in the next few weeks, and they may well remember Gloria, the dog and the song when they do. Whether that memory walks them through John Lewis’s doors depends less on how they felt on the sofa than on whether anyone gave them a reason and an easy way to act, because warmth earns the memory and something else has to earn the sale.
Which lens does a Christmas ad have to win for you? If you would like to see which lenses tend to lead in your own decisions, the STAR Cognitive Profile Assessment at starassess.com takes 33 questions, and the assessment and its full report are both free.
David Chadderton is a behavioural strategist, Chief Marketing Officer and STAR Dynamics. He writes The Unoptimised Human.
References
Advanced Television. (2026, 4 November). John Lewis 2026 Xmas ad scores high with System1. Advanced Television.
Advanced Television. (2026, 12 November). Analysis: Morrisons, Sainsbury’s lead in most effective Xmas advert. Advanced Television.
Binet, L., & Field, P. (2013). The Long and the Short of It: Balancing Short and Long-Term Marketing Strategies. Institute of Practitioners in Advertising.
Chadderton, D. (2026). Dear Algorithm, It’s Not Me, It’s You: Putting the Personal Back Into Personalisation (2nd ed.).
Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, Fast and Slow. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Moors, A., Ellsworth, P. C., Scherer, K. R., & Frijda, N. H. (2013). Appraisal theories of emotion: State of the art and future development. Emotion Review, 5(2), 119–124.
Shakespeare, S. (2026, 13 November). How have the public reacted to this year’s John Lewis ad? YouGov.
Worfolk-Smith, B. (2026, 3 November). You Can’t Always Get What You Want. But Does The New John Lewis Xmas Ad Actually Deliver? DAIVID.
Eight minutes. Thirty-three questions.
A precise picture of how you operate: motivations, decision style, and blind spots. Free to start.
- S
- T
- A
- R
The canonical source.
Essays, when there is something worth sending. Choose the subjects you want. I will ask you to confirm the address before I write.